The Continuing Problem Of Domestic Violence Social Work Essay

Domestic Violence ( DV ) continues to be a important societal job in our society.

An even more complex issue is the impact of DV on parental mental wellness ( PMH ) and later the consequence this has on the psychological development, societal competency and personal wellbeing of kids populating with parents in these environments. Furthermore, DV and PMH are complicated issues in the kingdom of societal work pattern and an on-going subject of international argument from authorities organic structures, cosmopolitan services, research workers, authors and subsisters.As the rubric suggests, this thesis will concentrate on the inter-connected demands of grownups and kids populating in environments where PMH and DV are prevailing.The thesis is structured with an debut to the capable rubric and a brief outline of chapter content. Throughout the writer makes mention to political, ethical, theoretical and legal constructs to back up statements.Chapter One presents definitions of both DV and mental wellness, nomenclature used in the capable countries along with background information.

Best services for writing your paper according to Trustpilot

Premium Partner
From $18.00 per page
4,8 / 5
Writers Experience
Recommended Service
From $13.90 per page
4,6 / 5
Writers Experience
From $20.00 per page
4,5 / 5
Writers Experience
* All Partners were chosen among 50+ writing services by our Customer Satisfaction Team

Chapter Two will analyze and discourse the physical and psychological effects of Domestic Violence on adult females. Chapter Three will critically turn to how PMH and DV impacts on kid development. Chapter Four will measure societal work pattern and intercessions relevant to both DV and mental wellness, and eventually, Chapter Five will critically measure current and past research particular to societal work pattern.

Definitions of Domestic Violence and Mental Health

“ The cicatrixs you ca n’t see are the 1s you carry for life. ”

( Sane Responses Seminar Report, 2003 )


The Home Office defines Domestic Violence ( DV ) as any incident of endangering behavior, force, or maltreatment ( psychological, physical, sexual, fiscal or emotional ) between grownups who are or have been intimate spouses or household members, irrespective of gender or gender ( Home Office, 2000 )Stanko ( 2000 ) cites that culprits of DV come from diverse socio economic and cultural backgrounds, including physicians, Judgess, attorneies, and constabulary officers.

Acerate leaf to state, work forces can besides be victims of DV, but adult females sustain more than 90 five per centum of hurts during incidents of DV ( Stanko, 2000 ) .The Nottinghamshire Domestic Violence Forum ( 2008 ) draws our attending to Acts of the Apostless of DV that can attest through the commission of forced matrimonies, and illegal activities such as ‘honour ‘ offenses and female venereal mutilation. An article in the Middle East Quarterly ( 2009 ) highlights the badness of honour offenses and the similar features between honour offenses and DV ( see Appendix ( A ) .

Honour offenses are specific to the Asiatic communities where adult females are killed because they have shamed their household name, or their behaviour/attitude threatens to make so. There is a distinguishable difference in the Western construct of DV, chiefly perpetrated between intimate spouses or antique spouses, in comparing to the construct of honour violent deaths where household members ( male, female, brother, sister, mother etc ) condone this type of maltreatment. Devriess ( 1996 ) argues that although civilization can enable self-respect and societal position, supplying support, protection and security, it besides has the power to harm and dis-empower persons.All signifiers of DV come from the culprit or maltreaters desire for power and control over household members or intimate spouses ( Women ‘s Aid, 2007 ) . However, culprits would reason that their logical thinking behind DV is that associating to emphasize, external factors such as unemployment, hapless lodging, cultural want or substance abuse ( Gilchrist, 2003 ) .Richard Smith ‘s article in The Guardian ( March, 2010 ) criticises the National Health Service for non taking force against adult females earnestly. The article high spots that adult females sing DV entree their GP five times more than the norm.

The World Health Organisation ( WHO ) ( 2002 ) studies findings of 10 different states on the prevalence of DV. The findings from these surveies illustrate unambiguously that one in four adult females experience DV over their life-times and between 6 and 10 per cent of adult females suffer DV in any given twelvemonth.

History & A ; Background to Domestic Violence

Heise ( 1998 ) considers domestic force, non as a new phenomenon, but an overpoweringly gendered opprobrious power, reinforced by patriarchal tradition, household and community doctrine with adult females following a submissive and low-level function, which in some states and civilizations is compliant to day of the month. As a consequence, it can be argued that non merely work forces, but adult females were responsible for accepting male domination as normative behavior ( Dobash & A ; Dobash, 2000 ) .Research workers have examined assorted theoretical models in seeking to place the beginnings, causes and most plausible grounds for DV ( Dobash and Dobash, 1980 ) . Some of the most relevant positions include those of the Social Learning Theory developed by Bandaura, 1977 which uses thoughts from the larning theory to look at how complex societal behavior is acquired.

Bandaura ‘s experimental acquisition theory can be positively or negatively reinforced by parents or other grownups. Beckett ( 2002 ) argues kids were more likely to copy behavior theoretical accounts that are seen to be rewarded for their actions, successful or have high profiles and position and those which they see as most similar to themselves ( Television, advertisement, famous persons ) .

Cycle of Violence

Resulting from a survey conducted in the USA, in 1979 Lenore Walker developed the theory that DV occurs in a rhythm. ( See Figure 1 )

Figure 1: Cycle of Violence

Beginning: Dr Lenore Walker, 1979, USA.

Figure 1 shows how the maltreatment continues and how the stages in the circle/cycle inter-link ; associating the stages in the rhythm to the complex relationship between the adult female being abused and the culprit. Consequently, the detonation phase of the rhythm leaves adult females and kids most vulnerable. See besides Appendix ( B ) for an penetration into the behavior displayed by the culprit and why their behavior alterations so radically over clip.In Ancient Egypt adult females who were so bold to talk out against their hubbies were at hazard of being hit in their oral cavity with a brick ( Bourlet, 1990 ) . Similar behavior condoned in British society, until the 19th century. Legally hubbies had a right to crush their married womans with a stick so long as the stick was non broader than their ain pollex, for what was considered to be “ lawful rectification ” ( Bourlet, 1990 ) .

Therefore, tribunals condoned this behavior so long as it did n’t go on after 10 autopsy or at weekends to upset neighbors or interfere with supplication. ( Bourlet, 1990 ) . Historically, small attempt has been made to dispute the violent adult male ( Mullender 1996a ) . However, there is grounds to propose that in today ‘s society new statute law protects adult females from DV and culprits are now held more accountable for their actions in the condemnable justness system ( Buzawa & A ; Buzawa 2003 ) .


Domestic Violence will be used throughout as the most common term used in society. Hague and Malos ( 1993 ) discuss force as both direct and indirect opprobrious behaviors and does non needfully intend the culprit resides in the house as the culprits may go on to bring down force and maltreatment after the adult female or culprit has left.

Definitions of Mental Health

“ There is no wellness without Mental Health ( WHO, 2007 )

There are many disputing positions on what constitutes mental wellness. The cardinal facet of MH is clear from the definition of wellness in the WHO fundamental law: “ Health is a province of complete physical, mental and societal wellbeing and non simply the absence of disease or frailty. ” ( WHO, 2007 ) . Mental Health can be interpreted by assorted professionals and civilizations otherwise, definitions being influenced by gendered outlooks ( Sane Report, 2003 ) .The Sane Report ( 2003 ) lists the undermentioned as symptoms of hapless MH a individual may see: -“ .

.. denial, deficiency of get bying mechanisms, inability to map, depression, deficiency of control, low ego regard, intuition, paranoia, self harm self-destructive, isolation, fright anxiousness, denial, experiencing detached and misunderstood, loss of assurance and independency, deformation, confusion, memory loss and station traumatic emphasis upset ( PTSD ) as indexs of mental wellness jobs. ”Bracken and Thomas ( 2005 ) argue that our cognition of MH and hurt is uncomplete and new ways of believing about MH issues are continually emerging. Coppock and Hopton ( 2000 ) pull attending to the wealth of grounds admiting that MH is non simply a biological issue, but is besides affected by societal and political fortunes, and environmental force per unit areas such as rejection and stigmatization.

The Sane Response Report ( 2003 ) estimates that one in four of us will see a MH job at some point in our lives.


The nomenclature used around MH can be both labelling and confounding. MH is a common term used in society to depict person who has experienced MH issues or emotional hurt ( Open University, 2006 )For the intent of this thesis the writer will discourse MH issues in relation to Parental Mental Health ( PMH ) and the impact this has on the attention provided to the kid and the parental hazard factors of MH issues combined with DV.

Chapter Two:

Psychological Effectss of Domestic Violence on Women

Psychological hurt begins a complex form of actions and reactions which have a go oning impact over the class of one ‘s life ( Dodd, 2004 ) . A adult female ‘s long term experiences of DV may take to hapless physical and psychological operation, damaged ego esteem/confidence and other emotional cicatrixs caused by old ages of maltreatment ( Dodd, 2004 ) . Therefore, Astbury, 1999 ; O’Keane, 2000 ; Humpreys, 2003 ; Vidgeon, 2003 and Humphrey ‘s and Thiara, 2003 cited in Women ‘s Aid, 2008 study that DV ( and other maltreatment ) is the most prevailing cause of depression, PTSD, ego injury and self-destructive inclinations in adult females.More than half of the adult females who entree MH services have experienced DV in the yesteryear, with more than a one-fourth presently sing DV ( DOH, 2003 ; Bowstead, 2000 ; ReSisters, 2002 cited in The Survivors Handbook ( 2009 ) Aid, The international survey by Tolman and Rossen ( 2001 ) acknowledge psychological emphasis has the strongest impact on a adult female ‘s physical and MH wellbeing, adult females were 3 times more likely to see many psychiatric upsets in comparing to adult females in non-violent relationships.The London Safeguarding Children ‘s Board ( 2008 ) suggest that adult females who experience DV are more likely than their equals in non opprobrious relationships to endure from some signifier of substance dependence whether it be illicit or prescription based as a header scheme. Harmonizing to Women ‘s Aid ( 2008 ) , adult females sing DV are 15 times more likely to misapply intoxicant and 9 times more likely to misapply drugs.

A research survey in 2003 by Humphreys & A ; Thiara ( 2003 ) examines literature reappraisals of response to MH and DV in both the UK and North America. In brief, these findings acknowledge an endearing connexion between DV and mental wellness, exemplifying the earnestness and prevalence and the effects and effects of the impact of station traumatic emphasis ( PTSD ) , suicide, self injury, being referred to as ‘symptoms of maltreatment ‘ ( Humphreys and Thiara, 2003 ) . From the same survey, the perceptual experience of adult females interviewed suggest their histories of emotional maltreatment are likely to be misconstrued, misunderstood and perchance used against them.

Consequently, these responses generate a clime of opinion and intuition ensuing in many adult females larning how to last by hushing their voices ( Van Hook, 2000 )Stanley, et Al, ( 2003 ) speculates on research undertaken in Islington which defines the humiliation, devaluation of the ego and entrapment as life events most likely to arouse depression. Corroboratively, Cascardi et Al, ( 1999 ) and Golding ( 1999 ) suggest 46 per cent of adult females with depression from DV.Rethink ( 2006 ) undertook a comparatively little research survey on 60 South Asiatic adult females ( aged between 22 and 60 ) in the North Kent country of London who expressed their positions on DV, MH and in-migration.

Of the 53 per cent interviewed, 75 per cent were incognizant of services available around DV and MH but were every bit loath to entree services for grounds such as in-migration and fright of being labelled. Symptomatically, this is non surprising as adult females in the survey are already oppressed because of their race and civilization. However, an overpowering 85 per cent articulated an apprehension of DV and how it affects them emotionally and physically, 33 per cent placing populating with depression and emotional hurting as a direct consequence of DV.

Nonetheless, accepting this as portion of their traditions and values and their duty to maintain the regard ( izzat ) their household clasp in the community, and avoid delivery shame ( sharam ) on the household name. South Asiatic adult female expressed in the study “ it is a adult female ‘s responsibility to accept everything in a matrimony and to believe things will acquire better as life moves on. ”“ Maltreatment is maltreatment is n’t it, physical is worse than mental but if you are mentally disquieted life is hell, so life is snake pit.

” ( Rethink, 2006 ) Culturally, females are oppressed and male laterality is supported within that civilization ( Wood & A ; Roche, 2001 ) . Braun & A ; Clarke, 2006 acknowledge that sensitive experiences are alone to the participant ‘s beliefs, perceptual experiences and traditions. Womans from the survey were able to portion how priceless it is in placing the manner they create intending and insight into their life experiences in the societal hierarchy of their civilization ( Riger, 1992 ) . Findingss besides suggest that immature, married South Asiatic adult females are a high hazard group for self-destruction ( Rethink, 2006 ) .Social and cultural norms of behavior which may be different for minorities are sometimes interpreted as marks of mental upsets ( WHO, 2005 ) .

The Sainsbury ‘s Centre for Mental Health ( 2004 ) studies on the ‘fear ‘ factor of Black and Ethnic Minorities ( BME ) with MH jobs. Fear is frequently a term associated with the BME group, both from a service user perspective and from professionals handling, or coming into contact with this service user group. It is arguable how effectual appraisal or ‘professional ‘ support webs are if they openly display fear towards service users? ( National Institute of Mental Health NIMH, 2003 ) .

Research undertaken in Europe and North America ( Pilgrim and Rogers, 1999 cited in Stanley et Al, 2003 ) implies that minority cultural adult females are less likely to seek aid than their white opposite numbers. Supporting this impression is the 6 per cent self-destruction rate amongst BME groups with MH issues ( NIMH, 2003 ) .In the early 1990 ‘s it was estimated that the cost of handling depression in adult females sing DV was about, ?105,252,000. Walby, 2004 cited in Women ‘s Aid, 2008 estimates the figure at ?176,000,000. Smith, reports in an article in The Guardian ( 2008 ) the influence of a state ‘s economic crisis, such as the recession in the UK, and how reported incidents of DV are increasing, no uncertainty holding fiscal deductions for the state in wellness and societal attention.

Several surveies ( Coker, Smith, Lesa, King & A ; McKeown, 2000 ; Eby, Campbell, Sullivan & A ; Davidson, 1995 cited in Yeung, 2002 ) bring to illume the diverse facets associated with physical wellness complaints of adult females sing DV, ( including disablement, chronic hurting, megrim, sexually transmitted infections and many more are all important, nevertheless, the hazard factors besides associated with physical hurt are those that can take to human death ( Campbell & A ; Soeken, 1999 ) Research undertaken by McGee ( 2000 ) of 54 kids and 48 female parents report 71 per cent of those kids witnessed their female parent being physically assaulted and 10 per cent witnessed their female parent being raped.( Smith, Thornton, De Vellis, Earp, & A ; Coker, 2002 ) suggests physical force seldom occurs independently from psychological maltreatment, and ( Henning & A ; Klesgen, 2003 ) makes mention to psychological maltreatment predating physical force. Marshall ( 1999 ) suggests there are three different types of maltreatment harmful to adult females: Obvious: include verbal ill will and domineering behaviors. Overt: incorporates ordering and insensitive behaviors. Subtle: consist of societal isolation and undermining behaviors.Corrigan and Penn ( 1997 ) mostly define two different theoretical attacks to MH- the disease/medical theoretical account and the social/discriminatory theoretical account.

The medical theoretical account is specific to diagnosis ‘medicate and travel on ‘ . Given the context of the capable affair this attack clearly does non turn to all facets, such as societal jobs. Mullender ( 2000 ) argues that a important figure of adult females showing within the MH sphere are falsely diagnosed with specific mental unwellnesss, when in consequence they are reactions to reiterate, digesting force and emotional torment. Hager ( 2001 ) argues that statements such as ‘domestic force thrusts adult females brainsick ‘ is damaging to a adult female ‘s character if interpreted out of context and considered truthful.

However, from the same research adult females do propose that emotional maltreatment makes them experience as if they are traveling mad.Womans who have experienced sexual maltreatment from an confidant spouse, Finkelhor & A ; Yllo ( 1985 ) , Russell ( 1990 ) cited in Pandora ‘s Project ( 2008 ) have compared their experience of colza, to people who have been held surety.A adult female that experiences physical DV is reported to psychologically go forth the relationship over and over once more ( Hyden, 1999 ) . However, Walkers ( 1979 ) rhythm of force identifies the dependance factor an emotional fond regard, and an facet of trueness to their spouse and household values. ( Campbell, Rose, Kub and Nedd, 1998 ) suggests that despite a adult female ‘s erudite weakness as a header scheme, adult females can besides be resilient and resourceful to their state of affairs.Melzer ( 2003 ) estimates that in the UK, 30 per cent of the population who have come into contact with specializer MH services have dependent kids, and 7 per cent live in solitary parent families.

Chapter THREE

Impact of Parental Mental Health and Domestic Violence on Parenting Capacity and Child Development

“ Children go the victims or the donees of grownup actions. ”

Cunningham, H. ( 2006 )

The analysis of matter-of-fact research undertaken over a 20 twelvemonth period corroborates that kids exposed to DV are over-represented in these environments and, is a turning public concern ( ) .

It is estimated between 11 and 20 per cent of kids in the USA are exposed to DV in their childhood ( Fantuzzo et. , al. , 2003 ) .( Stanley, et al.

, 2003 ) found that parents who had sustained physical or psychological hurts from a spouse, were more than probably to be unaccessible and unresponsive to a kid ‘s demands. Targosz et al. , 2003 argues that female parents in complex life environments described rearing as an extra emphasis factor ensuing in incompatibility and capriciousness to their parenting capacity. Parents may go reliant on emotional and practical support from their kids, and unrealistic outlooks for ego attention and adulthood ( Stanley, et Al, 2003 ) . However, comparative research in ( Holden and Ritchie et. al. , 1998 ) found some parents were able to show positive and protective parenting, including physical fondness, sometimes described as being excess vigilant and over nurturing.Measuring the rearing function can be rather hard from two spheres, as MH services use powerful negative testimony when measuring rearing capacity ( Humphreys, 2000 ; Stanley & A ; Penhale, 1999 ) .

It is estimated that between 3 and 10 million kids witness DV against a parent by a spouse or close comparative and are at higher hazard of being abused themselves ( Straus, 1992 ) . Daniel & A ; Wassell ( 2002 ) alarmingly reported 70 per cent of kids were physically abused during incidents of force between parents. Similarly, Walby ( 2004 ) studies three quarters of kids were either in the following room or witnessed DV, or at least half of which were either injured, or severely beaten.Childs are every bit at hazard of copying their parents ‘ behavior, going culprits and victims in their ain confidant relationships, a go oning rhythm of maltreatment and emotional inharmoniousness ( Research to Practice, 2008 ) . Sometimes their experiences are overlooked and minimised, frequently go forthing them with lasting emotional and psychological cicatrixs ( Research to Practice, 2008 ) . However, non all kids react the same to state of affairss, their header schemes and resiliency differ, depending on their emotional and physical strengths and failings and their evident ‘resilience ‘ may be internalised ( Hughes, Graham-Bermann, & A ; Gruber, 2001 cited in National Centre for Children Exposed to Domestic Violence, 2008 ) . Children rely on their parents for the raising and counsel they need to turn towards independency. Daniel and Wassell ( 2002, p.

13 ) defines resiliency as “ the capacity to exceed hardship ” .


The Bronfenbrenners Ecological Model of Child Development ( see Appendix C ) considers the kid as cardinal to the state of affairs, concentrating on the quality and context of the kid ‘s environment, associating to systems as relationships and doing mention non merely to who in the household has a job, but what the kid demands. ( Bronfenbrenners, 1989 in Daniel et Al, 1999 ) cites that kids should non be assessed in “ isolation ” as they do non turn up in a “ vacuity ” and, as grownups, are affected by the multilayered cloth of political and societal webs that influence day-to-day life.

Harmonizing to Bandura ‘s ( 1977 ) social-learning theory, people observe other people ‘s behavior, known as experimental acquisition ( or patterning ) and is used to explicate different types of behavior. For illustration, when analysing aggression, males who have witnessed DV during their childhood may be of the temperament that this behavior is the norm and may commit force in their ain grownup relationships.


John Bowlby ‘s celebrated theory of fond regard ( 1980, 1982 ) is cardinal in measuring the quality of attention the primary health professional demonstrates towards the kid ( in footings of health professional reactivity ) . However where there is confusion in the kid ‘s fortunes, the kid does non develop a consistent or coherent scheme for obtaining aid and comfort from the health professional, viz. their female parent ( Zeanah et al. 1999 ) .Mary Ainsworth ( 1978 ) analyzes the sensitivity of human existences to develop strong emotional bonds with others, get downing in babyhood and go oning through maturity ( Bowlby, 1982 ) . Consequently, violence-prone persons may be covering with attachment issues stemming from their ain childhood ( Kesney, Julian, & A ; McKenry, 1997 ) .

Research on babyhood fond regard ( Waters et. al. , 2000 ) has shown that the more serious the degree of spouse force, the higher the likeliness of insecure fond regards, describing over 70 per cent of babies in ‘average ‘ families are by and large classified as ‘securely attached ‘ . West & A ; George, ( 1999 ) suggest over 50 per cent of babes in a sample of female parents exposing terrorization or frightened behaviour from DV were considered to advance disorganized fond regard.


Violence against pregnant adult females has been referred to as ‘child maltreatment in the uterus ‘ ( Hunt and Martin, 2001 ) . During gestation adult females every bit good as the unborn are at hazard of injury, frequently referred to in research as ‘double intentioned force ‘ ( Kelly, 1994 ) . Studies undertaken by Campbell ( 2002 ) and Schornstein ( 1997 ) highlight the addition in abortions.It is estimated that 30 per cent of adult females may be subjected to DV during gestation, a period when DV either starts or escalates ( Bewley & A ; Mezey, 1997 ) .

Perry ( 1997 ) discourse how DV impacts on a adult female ‘s general reproductive and psychological wellness, although the psychological facet is non readily acknowledged as the formative is prioritised. At birth, a babe ‘s encephalon is 25 per cent its grownup weight, increasing to 66 per cent by the terminal of the first twelvemonth ( Perry, 1997 ) Research on encephalon development suggests that exposure to extreme injury can alter the administration of the encephalon and may cut down the size of the babe ‘s caput ( Lou, 1994 ) . Exposure to force can straight, or indirectly affect the fetus, doing physical hurts and possible decease ( Morey, 1981 )

Emotional, Educational and Physical Development

Mullender et Al, 2002 highlights the hazards for kids populating in families of force is threefold: hazard of detecting traumatic events, hazards of physical injury and the hazard of being neglected as a consequence of parents ain physical and MH issues impacting on their day-to-day operation.

Margolin ( 1998 ) suggests that the harm kids experience emotionally from witnessing DV is merely every bit harmful as them enduring physical maltreatment.Children life in families affected by PMH and DV are identified as “ at hazard ” under the Adoption and Children Act, 2002: from 31 January 2005. Section 120 of this act extended the legal definition of harming kids to include injury suffered by seeing or hearing sick intervention of others. Similarly, parents who are sing PMH and DV may non hold the ability or motive to supply fondness and stimulation to their kid, ensuing in emotional maltreatment. ( Garbarino & A ; Garbarino, 1994 )The unsafe circumstance of place is upseting and disrupts kids ‘s patterned advance through age-appropriate developmental undertakings ( Margolin & A ; Gordis, 2000 ) .Beginning: Adapted from National Center on Domestic Violence Trauma and Mental HealthFigure 2 symbolises the impact on kids populating in environments with DV and PMH from construct digesting complexnesss into maturity and the distinguishable possibility of early decease.

( Velitti et. , Al, 2004 )( Margolin, 1998 ) Children exposed to DV may react to adult choler with greater hurt and additions in aggression directed at equals ( Margolin, 1998 ) . If kids learn in their earliest relationships that grownups are non to be relied upon, the effects are likely to be durable and far-reaching.The impact may be different for striplings who have been portion of an opprobrious system from their earliest old ages compared with an stripling who has been exposed to a violent environment for the first clip. Violence against female parents in childhood is extremely associated with ongoing depression in adolescent misss ( Spaccarelli, Sandler & A ; Roosa, 1994 ) .

A consistent yarn running through research in the USA ( Kitzmann, Gaylord, Holt, Kenny, 2003: Wolfe, Crooks, Lee, McIntyre-Smith, Jaffe, 2003 ) recognise striplings are more likely to expose internalizing jobs such as anxiousness and depression ( Litrownik et. , Al. 2003 ) and externalised jobs ( Jaffee et al, 2002: and Levendosky et. , al 1998 ) describing higher degrees of aggression, ill will, hapless school attending, troubles concentrating in school resulting in both societal isolation and hapless academic public presentation.( Cummings & A ; Davies, 1994 ) cites 63 per cent of kids map at a lower degree than their equals, and at greater hazard of disregard, deficiency of support with instruction, extended behavior and emotional jobs when their victimised female parent ‘s experience psychological troubles. Children tend to see ( amongst others ) hyper watchfulness, straitening ideas and memories, bedwetting, witting turning away, and sleep troubles ( Mertin, & A ; Mohr, 2002 ) .

Consequently, Levendosky et. Al, ( 2002 ) confirms the relationship between the psychological effects that adult females experience from DV and adolescent mental wellness.The nexus between child physical maltreatment and DV is high, estimates runing between 30 per cent and 66 per cent depending upon the survey ( Hester et al, 2000 ) . From the same survey, it is common, unluckily, for parents who have been neglected or abused to go through on the manner they were treated to the manner they treat their ain kids, therefore this behavior may be trans-generational.It can be rather confounding for kids if they live in an environment where grownups offer them physical, emotional and basic attention but are besides culprits or victims ( Hester, et al. , 2000 ) .

Therefore, whilst female parents were preoccupied with seeking to keep their grownup relationship and their construct of a place environment, kids ‘s demands were slightly unmet ( Mullender et al. 2002 ) . An NSPCC Study ( 2002 ) estimated 9 out of 10 kids who experienced disregard, besides reported DV happening in the household place. For many of these kids, their childhood experience of consistence safety and attention is interrupted by uncertainness and weakness ( Hester, et al. , 2000 ) . A UNICEF study in 2006 rather justly suggests that advancement can non be made if vulnerable kids are overlooked and go on to be abused.

Herbert ( 2003 ) argues that older siblings, frequently in hard-pressed place fortunes, assume the responsibility of attention giver to siblings, ego and parent/s. This in bend can impact negatively on their instruction, wellness and societal life ( Becker, 2000 cited in Stanley et Al, 2003 ) . Children become less cognitively competent, less able to demo societal proficiency, less able to acquire along with equals and have developed emotional/or behavioral jobs ( Herbert 2003:292 ) . See besides ( Bee, 1995 ) which suggests kids who are non hugged, held or cared for do n’t turn ( Bee, 1995 ) One inquiries hence, how can a kid develop adequately as a kid if taking on duties delegated to parents/caregivers?Childs are simple in actuating their female parent in the direction of their opprobrious relationships. For more than half the participants in a research survey, something the kids said or did catalysed the adult female into seeking aid. ( Zink et al. , 2003 )By and large, research on the impact of DV on PMH on kids has focused on the negative results ( hazards ) from populating in these environment ( Bogart et al.

, 2006 ) . Osofsky ( 2003 ) theorizes that non all kids have negative experiences and this may be attributed to resilience or the parent-child relationship ( protective factor ) . Resilience, defined as “ the procedure of, capacity for, or result of successful version despite disputing or endangering fortunes ” ( Masten, Best & A ; Garmezy, 1990, p. 426 ) .Haskett et al. , ( 2006 ) discourse the experiences of kids exposed to complex environmental and societal factors, ensuing in maltreatment and disregard, illustrate that some kids adjust to their state of affairs and map positively.

Let us non bury those kids who become unseeable to services and hidden in a head covering of secretiveness to protect themselves and the victim from reverberations, or culturally inappropriate to portion experiences of household life ( Zukerman, et al. , 1995 ) .Few surveies exist in the UK foregrounding the extent of domestic force on adult females with physical, larning disablements and handicapped adult females from BME groups ( Vernon, 1998 ) . Their exposure is intensified by their demands and the DV in the relationship ( Cockram, 2003 ) . Disabled adult females are discerning to go forth an opprobrious relationship for fright of farther disability, dependance and farther favoritism or hazard holding demands unmet in a safety environment ( Cockram, 2003 ) . The NSPCC ( 1997 ) high spots that some handicapped kids may non be able to efficaciously pass on and portion their experiences, therefore their exposure is heightened.Harmonizing to the United Nations Convention 1989, all kids have the same rights, including the right to protection from harmful influences including maltreatment and development, and to take part to the full in household, cultural and societal life.

Chapter FOUR

Social Work Practice and Intervention

— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —

The public assistance of the kid is overriding.

( The Children Act, 1989 )

Key statute law for kids and household societal work pattern is the Children Act, 1989 and this should hold marked a difference in service bringing to this service user group ( Trevithick, 2000 ) The Children Act 2004 aims to foster better kids ‘s lives and gives the legal underpinning to ‘Every Child Matters: Change for Children ‘ ( 2004 ) . Of equal importance for pattern is the revised 2010 Working Together to Safeguard Children Guidelines.In the UK the societal work function is underpinned by the General Social Care Council ( GSCC, 2002 ) codification of pattern along with authorities guidelines, statute law and local authorization policies and processs.

Olsson and Ljunghill, ( 1997 ) citation Norse research workers are critical of organizational procedures environing societal work proposing although influential, they are restricted by regulations and unable to lend to effectual job resolution.Different schemes are undertaken to measure the effectivity of early intercession and bar in societal work pattern. In the UK early intercession and bar have become a cardinal policy country, cardinal to the Every Child Matters docket ( Pugh, 2007 ) .The sweep of services developed since the late 1990 ‘s is testament of the demand to undertake future hazards of vulnerable kids ( Pugh, 2007 ) and the demand for structured effectual service bringing as identified in The Every Child Matters statute law and Children ‘s Plan ( Department of Children Schools and Families, 2008a ) . Aspects of effectual early intercessions and bars work conceptualises maximizing protective and understating hazard factors ( Scots Summary, 2005 ) .

Farrinigton ( 2002 ) suggest that tacking these jobs requires coordinated multi-agency intercessions, which ( Crow et. Al, 2004 ) would reason has yet to be evidenced.Since 2002 several development enterprises and authorities recommendations ( UK Spending Review, 2002 ; Respect Task Force, 2006 and the Cabinet Office, 2008a ) recognize schemes needed to turn to non merely ’causes ‘ of hazard but besides targeted proviso for those already identified as ‘at hazard ‘ ( France et. Al, 2006 ) What is apparent is that societal workers need to understand that childhood can non be separated from its societal context ( Prout, 2000 ) and these factors: – the household ‘s life state of affairss and environments, household and societal relationships, societal and anti-social behavior, physical and psychological wellness and instruction and employment are complex ironss of effects ( Scots Summary, 2005 ) .The Australian Pathways Programme concentrates on constructing strengths in persons and households by promoting, authorization and battle, constructing resiliency and get bying schemes ( Ghate et. al.

, 2008 ) . Their usage of the Risk Factor Analysis ( RFS ) is a popular tool turn outing to be effectual, cost effectual and practical. However, it is non a new construct and is one of many tools, complimented by theoretical models when planning and implementing intercessions ( France, et. al.

, 2006 ) . France & A ; Homel ( 2006 ) highlight the importance of new thoughts and new directives in developing preventive pattern.It is of import for policy shapers to research international research as a learning experience and footing for pattern ( Social Work Task Force, 2009 ) and besides to ‘question the historical inevitableness of bing patterns in our ain state ‘ ( Baistow and Wilford, 2000: 344 ) .Seppanen ‘s 2008 survey into Finnish and Swedish societal work identifies research as an on-going activity, which necessitates the rating of societal work intercessions. The survey acknowledges the function of societal workers and how good to pattern and intercession research findings are. However, Boddy and Statham ( 2009 ) argue that the function of societal workers and their results are harshly criticised internationally.

From a similar survey by Hayes and Spratt ( 2008 ) they consider child protection and kid public assistance managed in the UK as an incorporate system. The survey significantly points out the issues of kids turning up in households entrenched with hardship and complexnesss, which may non be apparent until the following coevals. Hence, the rhythm of societal, economic and multiple jobs continue ( Spratt, 2001 ) .

This confirms the on-going subject of societal workers seeking to ‘break the rhythm ‘ and ‘bring about alteration ‘ .Khoo et. Al ( 2002 ) international kid public assistance and protection survey in Sweden and Canada confirm the gate-keeping procedure in these states is similar to that in the UK. The survey compactly reports that the Swedish public assistance system provides more preventative and supportive services from a kid in demand construct, taking to understate kids populating in poorness and sing kid disregard. In contrast, Canada ‘s pattern and intercession is from a kid protection position.

Historically, unifying kids and grownup services has ever been hard, with clear divides. Measuring the impact of MH on parenting is disputing for practicians, as their ain ‘specialist country ‘ makes them loath to do judgements because they lack acquaintance ( Stanley et al, 2003 ) . However, service bringing should be prioritised collaboratively, despite professional struggles ( Stanley et al, 2003 ) .Small and Mount ( 1999 ) defines bar as an effort to decrease the hazard of a societal or psychological job occurrence ; and intercession to help high hazard service users minimise injury to self and others from their societal and psychological jobs and entree support to forestall farther developments.The Children ‘s Workforce Development Council ( 2007 ) suggests societal work retains a considerable sum of power over service users lives in the appraisal of hazard. The UK Government clearly defines duty for safeguarding as a shared construct between all bureaus and professionals in analyzing information so that an appraisal can be made of the kid ‘s demands and fortunes. ( Government, 2006a, p.

34, 1.16 ) . Working Together to Safeguard Children ( HM Government 2006a ) and the Assessment Framework ( Department of Health et Al 2000 ) provide clear counsel on the processs societal workers should follow in measuring kids and households.The appraisal procedure considers all facets of the household, with the child cardinal to the procedure, ( Guralnick, 1997 cited in Seden, 1995 ) .

Humphreys ( 2003 ) argues that research is dominated by rearing capacity appraisals, nevertheless, societal workers have a responsibility to measure any predisposing factors such as PMH and DV, connoting a higher degree of hazard ( London Child Protection Procedures, 2007 ) .Assessment is a peculiarly of import portion of a kid attention practician ‘s work. The inter-connected demands of a kid ‘s development and parents ‘ ague and chronic troubles are important to any appraisal, as is the demand to measure strengths in every bit much item as countries of concern ( Hester & A ; Westmarland ( 2005 ) . Research surveies ( Cleaver et. , al 1999 ) high spot PMH, parental substance abuse and DV as important hazard factors strongly related to child maltreatment. In response, there is grounds in the UK ( Nottingham Children ‘s Servicess, 2010 ) that an updated attack to appraisals considers a ‘trilogy of concerns ‘ towards complex appraisals and hazard analysis. This construct works on the rule that despite the presenting issue, parents must be assessed for DV, MH and substance abuse, working on the procedure of riddance so as non to overlook or understate the concerns and forestall ill-informed determination devising to the hurt of the kid ( Cleaver et.

al 1999 ) .Using the systems attack, as described by Compton and Galaway ( 1989, pp.123-137 ) , aids practicians to understand information about their functions and duties, multi-agency operation and the systems environing service users ; whereas Saleby ( 1997 ) describes the demand for practicians to follow the strengths attack to assessment to enable solution focused and job resolution decisions.

( Cleaver, et. al. , 1999 ) highlights the importance of seeing kids independently from their health professional to obtain their wants and feelings and to develop an apprehension of how a kid feels populating in such environments ( Hart and Powell 2006: p.19 )Some research into the positions of service users suggest societal work intercessions are frequently positive and protective but besides an avenue for service users to see their state of affairs through fresh eyes and how this impacts on the kid ( Gilligan, 2001 ) . On the reverse, some report societal work intercession as intrusive, critical of their parental function and labelling and faulting them for their kid ‘s experience ( Lingerfelt, 1974, Gingerich et al, 1982 cited in Payne 2003 ) .Guralnick ( 1997 ) evidences the importance of effectual early intercession for handicapped kids and to forestall maltreatment. Humphrey ‘s and Mullender ( 2000 ) see the effects of research in pattern concentrating the policy, theoretical and pattern intercessions of turn toing DV and PMH. It is clear from the survey that pattern intercessions have developed significantly over clip to include positive direct work with kids, as the preventative or early intercessions can cover a broad scope of jobs, ague and chronic and affecting kids of all ages ( Small and Mount 1999 ) .

Perry ( 1997 ) nevertheless, argues the troubles in conveying about alteration to kids and households that experience injury and emphasis, despite their ability.The National Center on Domestic Violence, Trauma and Mental Health established in 2005 identifies the demand for multi bureau coaction to advance an apprehension of the MH and protagonism demands of subsisters of DV and their kids. The ‘Model of Change ‘ ( see Appendix D ) – a tool devised to help effectual pattern in turn toing all facets in relation to service bringing.

Evidence based pattern strengthens the usage of research findings in pattern, therefore helping societal workers in measuring their ain effectivity ( Healey 2005 ) . It is necessary to joint the cognition base for decision-making, particularly when such determinations may interfere with the civil autonomies of service users ( Healey 2005 ) , which Healey besides identifies as “ … particularly of import for determination devising in high hazard state of affairss in Fieldss such as kid protection and mental wellness ” ( Healey 2005:99 ) Furthermore, the primary/development, secondary/institutional and third theoretical accounts, identified by Hardiker ( 1991 ) are conducive and complimentary as specializer services which societal workers can draw a bead on to in their preventive attacks.

Chapter FIVE


“ Mistakes are an inevitable portion of pattern and recognizing them is an indispensable component of good pattern ” ( Munro, 1996, page 795 ) .

Unfortunately, Government Inquiries into the serious hurt or decease of a kid have often identified a failure of bureaus to work together as a cardinal factor ; an issue forcibly raised in the 2003 Victoria Climbie Inquiry Report and important instance reappraisals since that day of the month. In response the Government introduced the Children Act 2004 and a raft of attach toing counsel to back up better multi-agency coaction.Lord Laming ( 2009 ) identifies DV, MH issues and substance usage as the worst combination in footings of direct injury to kids.

However, traditionally research into this country of concern has been investigated as separate entities, with services and policies developed at different phases and by different groups ( Tunnard, 2004 )What has emerged from research is the interesting construct of what risk the culprit nowadayss, and how is this so challenged for them to accept duty and admit the effects to their households ( Devaney, 2008 ) .The current societal and policy context developing incorporates non merely the societal facet but legal, medical and educational attacks to embrace the single demands of service users, with accent to protect from important injury, whilst maintaining the household together ( O’Loughlin and O’Loughlin ( 2008 ) .Practitioners, are invariably faced with organizational bureaucratism, such as resource handiness and the most cost effectual manner to pattern within the restraints of budget restrictions ( Coulshed & A ; Mullender, 2006 ) . Research undertaken in four England and Wales governments highlights the effectivity of the Integrated Children ‘s System when working with kids in demand ( Cleaver et al, 2008 ) proposing good pattern can be improved by cultural and structural alterations, decrease in the bureaucratic policies faced by practicians and an addition in capacity to present quality service bringing, carry out thorough appraisals and make up one’s mind on the most appropriate intercessions ( Gupta & A ; Blewitt, 2007 cited in Cleaver et Al, 2008 )Barriers to accepting and take up of services by BME communities is an common entity as they fear being labelled, misunderstood or by and large treated otherwise to their white opposite numbers ( Mama, 1996 ) . Structural barriers for PMH and kids ‘s services appear to be unprioritised on the commissioning docket along with PMH for Black Minority Ethnic ( BME ) groups and service users with disablements. These groups have been identified as two of the four groups to confront barriers in turn toing their wellness and societal demands.

( SCIE, 2009 ) .Effective bar and early intercession activities are normally conceptualised in footings of hiking protection and cut downing hazard factors ( Hester and Westmarland, 2005 ) . “ The terminal end is to supply high quality comprehensive services to those who seek aid from the assisting professions. ” ( Thompson, 2006, p.2 )