The Statutory Interventions In Social Work Social Work Essay

Mental wellness services have antecedently been to a great extent dominated by wellness service attitudes reinforced by medical theoretical accounts of account and beliefs, making a division between the mentally sick and society. The laterality over biochemical attacks to mental wellness has so far presented small infinite for the look of a more holistic option, ( Tew, 2002 ) .

Literature suggests that mental wellness services need to travel beyond the bio chemical attack, which has created a division between the ‘normal ‘ and the ‘mentally sick ‘ , by specifying their ‘illness ‘ in footings of their ‘pathology ‘ , ( Bainbridge, 1999 ) , into a pattern which incorporates societal work values underpinned by the societal theoretical account of mental wellness.

‘2009 will be a important twelvemonth for mental wellness policy in England. ‘ ( New Vision for Mental Health, 2008 )

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!

order now

As the authoritiess 10-year scheme for mental wellness, the ‘ National Service Framework ‘ , is coming to an terminal important policy alterations are being made. Amendments which have been made to the Mental Health Act 1983 have radically changed mental wellness pattern with alterations in the functions and duties of qualified mental wellness professionals, including debut of two new functions: the responsible clinician ( RC ) , officially the registered medical officer, ( RMO ) and approved mental wellness professional ( AMHP ) , officially known as the Approved Social Worker ( ASW ) . There has besides been increased involvement in societal theoretical accounts and attacks to mental wellness, which is being supported through administrations such as, ‘The Social Perspectives Network ‘ ( SPN ) , a web of people interested in how societal factors contribute to people going distressed. ( SPN, 2009 ) .

With these alterations in head and programs for societal attention and wellness services to work together on a more incorporate service bringing, the inquiry is- where does this go forth the function of societal work pattern in the hereafter.

This literature reappraisal will concentrate on the altering attacks to mental wellness pattern. Based on the literature provided it will analyze why the medical theoretical account has dominated mental wellness patterns in the yesteryear, and what the societal theoretical account accents, concentrating on psycho-social positions. It will put a critical position on the medical theoretical account and purpose to demo why increased accent on the societal theoretical account may hold encouraged a displacement in policy and statute law, ( amendments to the Mental Health Act 1983 ) . It will besides concentrate on how the societal theoretical account can act upon future societal work pattern.

‘Social work ‘s function in relation to psychopathology and the mental wellness system is peculiarly unsure ‘ . ( Beresford, 2005 ) .

As intercessions within mental wellness are chiefly medical theoretical account based, the function of societal work within the multi disciplinary led service remains ill-defined. It has been noted that medical theoretical accounts have been the ‘driving force ‘ , of policy and process within mental wellness. ( Carpenter, 2002 ) , and the dominant intervention paradigm in most mental wellness patterns ( Beecher, 2009 ) . However in footings of societal work, this theoretical account is damaging to services users self deserving and consequently struggles with a figure of societal work values, ( Carpenter, 2002 ) .

The medical theoretical account is a position that is adopted by physicians and head-shrinkers, proposing that mental unwellness is rooted in our physiology and is treated as a ‘disease ‘ or ‘illness ‘ , ( Golightly, 2008 ) and although unfavorable judgments exist, it has been favoured by practicians within the wellness attention system, as a tool for helping their pattern ( Boyle et al, 2006 ) . It can be described as

‘The predominant Western attack to illness, the organic structure being a complex mechanism, with illness understood in footings of causing and redress, in contrast to holistic, and societal theoretical accounts ‘ , ( Braye, 1992 ) .

It is proposed by head-shrinkers that ‘the ‘medical theoretical account ‘ is a procedure whereby, informed by the best available grounds, physicians advise on, co-ordinate or present intercessions for wellness betterments ‘ . ( Shal and Mountain, 2007 ) . This theoretical account characteristically seeks to place the job by a ‘diagnosis ‘ so prescribe medicine as a signifier of intervention to ‘eradicate ‘ or ‘rehabilitate ‘ the job, ( Kihlstrom, 2002 ) , nevertheless critics province that this ‘diagnosis ‘ consequences in the service user going an unwellness instead than an single. ( Deegan, 1996 ) .

Supporters of a more holistic attack would reason that the median theoretical account is guilty of being ‘too restricted ‘ and ‘problem focused ‘ , it besides maintains the depersonalization of the person with mental ‘illness ‘ , and their households, ( McLean, 1990 ) . In dependence it is excessively simplistic in taking into history the many variables that are in a individuals environment ( Ashford, et Al, 2006 ) , ( which may be a cause of their ‘diagnosis ‘ ) concentrating excessively frequently on their symptoms and shortages, non recognizing or prosecuting with the whole environment ( Rapp, 1998 ) . It besides ignores the person ‘s or households experiences, ( Barker et al, 2001 ) , which could besides hold an affect to their behavior ; it is guilty of non seeing the state of affairs holistically. ( Beresford, 2005 ) .

Other grounds suggests that societal causative factors, such as unemployment, unstable household fortunes, substance abuse and hapless instruction are more likely to explicate a individuals behaviour instead than any medical diagnosing, ( Taylor and Gunn, 1999 ) .

Although it has been noted that the medical theoretical account has been the more favorable attack in reenforcing policy and service proviso we can non state that the medical theoretical account, on its ain, is a sufficient footing to underpin policy and pattern in mental wellness, ( Carpenter, 2002 ) . As besides argued by Tew, ( 2002 ) , research which has been based on longitudinal studies shows that progresss in medical interventions have resulted in inconsistent recovery rates-so we can non state that the medical theoretical account is a sufficient tool to establish patterns on.

This raises the topic of the societal theoretical account, how does this theoretical account differ, what does the theoretical account emphasise? The undermentioned literature will take to place the cardinal rules in reply to these inquiries.

It has been established that the medical theoretical account sees the service user as an person with a job, instead than an person within an environment, which holds causable factors. Literature suggests nevertheless that the societal theoretical account takes a more ecological attack, ( Littlejohn, 2004 ) . So what is different about the societal theoretical account and how can it alter perceptual experiences in psychopathology?

Harmonizing to Ramon ( 2001 ) the societal theoretical account tantrums good within the holistic attack of societal work and is the implicit in principle for mental wellness societal work. Tyrer and Steinberg ( 2003 ) express that,

All societal theoretical accounts in psychopathology have the same cardinal premiss. They regard the wider influence of societal forces as more of import than other influences as causes or precipitants of mental unwellness ( Tyrer and Steinberg, 2003. p87 ) .

The societal theoretical account embraces the impact that societal causative factors and psychological factors can hold on a individual ‘s life. ( Duggan, 2002 ) particularly the impact it can hold on their wellness. It considers that persons enduring from socio-economic disadvantages ( such as societal exclusion and poorness ) can impact their wellness both physically and mentally, and are more likely to endure as a consequence of this.

Duggan ( 2002 ) supports the societal theoretical account and identifies clear cardinal features, which the societal theoretical account emphasizes. The impact of societal factors on persons who are vulnerable and the importance of keeping societal webs and support systems. Unlike the medical theoretical account, the societal theoretical account considers the inner and the outer universes of persons, underscoring authorization and capacity edifice at single and community degree and topographic points equal value on the expertness of service users, carers and the general populace, ( Tew, 2002 ) . Duggan goes farther and explains the theoretical account in more deepness,

‘The theoretical account allows practicians the opportunity to see mental hurt as a reaction to a scope of societal fortunes ( past and present ) that may be experienced. In this sense, it may frequently associate with issues of impotence and loss ‘ , ( Duggan, 2002 ) .

Smith explains his position on the societal theoretical account as apposed to the medical theoretical account and argues,

Behaviors defined as symptoms and upsets are best understood as originative responses to hard personal and societal histories, rooted in a individual ‘s experience of subjugation. ( Smith, 1999. p.31 ) .

The societal theoretical account accents cardinal features, which can be identified in societal work values, those of service user authorization, self-government and environment function in personal experience ( Carpenter, 2002 ) .

The general orientation of societal work values are helpful in achieving a more holistic attack, in that they promote a more user-centred societal work pattern and unite a committedness to work with persons and the environment which surrounds them, ( Tew, 2002 ) . Therefore the values that are at the bosom of societal work pattern sit more comfortably with what the societal theoretical account accents.

Both the medical and societal theoretical accounts have been discussed, foregrounding what each theoretical account emphasises, the literature has aimed to underscore why a displacement in policy and statute law may hold taken topographic point. The undermentioned literature will now look at the deductions for societal work.

Farone ( 2006 ) besides argues that societal work with its ecological position is good suited to turn to the complexnesss in mental wellness pattern. So how can societal work efficaciously step in within mental wellness services?

In a survey published by Rethink, ( Martyn, 2002 ) affecting 48 people with a schizophrenic diagnosing ( a common mental upset ) , they identified subjects in support countries which service users perceived as being effectual in their state of affairss – entree to paid and voluntary work, support with relationships with household and friends, reding and psychotherapeutics and instruction on wellness life, a similar research besides concluded these were of import, see Macdonald and Sheldon, ( 1997 ) .

These support countries embrace solutions beyond those recommended by medical diagnosing entirely.

Employment plays a cardinal function in undertaking societal exclusion ( a common societal cause of onset mental upset ) it besides provides the service user in assisting constructing self-pride every bit good as increasing societal capital and criterion of life. ( New Vision for Mental Health, 2008 ) . Loss of employment can accordingly hold inauspicious effects potentially making strain on mental wellness.

Literature suggests that the household is an of import beginning of support for services users with mental unwellness, and societal work should seek to maximise and prolong this support ( Reinaires and Vieta, 2004 ) . The societal theoretical account does admit that this imperative to any service users mental wellness as it is a cardinal facet of societal inclusion and plays a critical portion in recovery. Social work can in bend aid seek and prolong employment ( Beresford, 2005 ) .

However as acknowledged by a taking mental wellness administration,

‘Employment is an country where people with mental wellness jobs experience extended favoritism and disadvantage and be a beginning of damaging emphasis that causes mental sick wellness. ( Mind, 2009 ) .

This is an of import factor which societal work can efficaciously step in with, to undertake favoritism and support service users through prolonging work arrangements, to stay included. Social inclusion remains a big factor in keeping mental wellness as research suggests the societal theoretical account can lend to societal workers disputing societal exclusion ( Tew, 2002 ) . Huxley et Al ( 2003 ) identified the troubles services users face in prolonging and continuing societal contacts and societal webs, particularly when enduring from mental upsets.

In add-on Corry et Al ( 2004 ) besides found that people with mental wellness jobs who live in more stray rural countries with limited entree to services are likely to happen it more hard to develop and continue supportive societal contacts and webs. Social work function so is support service users in accessing and twenty-four hours Centres, and advance relationships between people who use services, promoting group work, which can take to disputing marginalization and favoritism, and in bend educate the user.

A psychological factor underpinned by the societal theoretical account that is overlooked by the medical theoretical account is the importance of household support, without this service the user could be at hazard of mental wellness impairment. ( Huxley et al, 2005 ) . Research suggests that keeping web relationships between household and services can hold important impact on mental wellness. It is suggested that a societal work function here would be to back up the web relationships, ( Germain and Gitterman, 1996 ) . However as acknowledged by Jack ( 2000 ) , relationships can be both supportive and nerve-racking and hence necessary to analyze the nature of the relationships to understand whether they were apt to help or weaken operation.

Direct payments, personal budgets and single budgets are at the Centre of the authorities ‘s purpose of personalizing grownup societal attention services around the demands of users. They involve direct hard currency payments given to service users to buy attention services, which they have been assessed as needing, and are intended to give users greater pick in their attention. Direct payments allow the user to use people or committee services for themselves and take on all the duties of an employer. ( Community Care, 2009 )

However research conducted by the Health Care Commission ( 2007 ) reported that direct payments for people with mental wellness jobs are under-used. Social work function here would be to recommend on behalf of the service user, working in partnership and easing authorization to increase entree to direct payments as suggested by Spandler and Vick, ( 2005 ) who conducted a survey into the use of Direct Payments.

The topic of societal work with a mental wellness pattern is a broad country of treatment. Unfortunately, the coverage of research surveies measuring societal work parts to mental wellness pattern is fickle and many countries of pattern remain under-researched.

There remains a spread in the research capturing the perceptual experiences of service users from marginalized groups, in peculiar positions of adult females with terrible mental upsets or those from lingual minorities. It is of import that societal work develops a greater apprehension within these Fieldss to understand their state of affairss holistically and in bend consequence in better entree to services, which basically underpins the societal theoretical account of pattern. With the turning involvement of the societal theoretical account within mental wellness to actively guarantee the best service bringing these issues of equality and diverseness need to be analysed.

There besides remained a spread in research of service users with double diagnosing, with the bulk of the research holding been undertaken in the United States. It should be stressed that due to medical research dominating societal research in double diagnosing and with a turning sum of service users falling within this country, more research is needed from a societal attention position.

There is besides the turning concern as the integrating of wellness and societal attention services evolves in the mental wellness ; societal workers function will go even more obscure. Social work practicians feel that their values, based on a societal theoretical account, will be controlled by wellness professions values, which in bend will follow a more medical theoretical account position. This concern has become more evident with the replacing of the ASW by the AMHP.

Due to this replacing, and the loss of a professional group, which had a clear individuality, the replacing, AMHPs will necessitate support to stay independent and develop a common attack, which underpins the societal theoretical account of pattern. As the AMHP ‘s could potentially be from a wellness attention background, it is the societal workers function to guarantee this convergence with other professions, continues to concentrate on the service user as an ‘individual ‘ , based on the societal theoretical account of mental upset, as appose to a ‘anti societal ‘ medical based theoretical account.


I'm Mack!

Would you like to get a custom essay? How about receiving a customized one?

Check it out